Adnan Syed walked out of court docket a free man on Monday after two handwritten notes that includes the title of one other potential suspect was found earlier this yr, it has been revealed.
Serial, the podcast which propelled the case to world consideration and first raised doubts about Syed’s conviction, launched a brand new episde on Tuesday revealing what lastly led Baltimore prosecutors to rethink the 41-year-old’s conviction for the 1999 homicide of his former girlfriend Hae Min Lee.
Within the episode, journalist Sarah Koenig stated that “messy” notes which languished in statet trial bins for greater than twenty years revealed that two totally different individuals had positioned two separate cellphone calls alerting prosecutors to the unnamed suspect previous to Syed’s 2000 conviction.
The notes weren’t shared with Syed’s authorized crew – one thing the decide agreed was a Brady violation.
On Monday, Choose Melissa Phinn overturned Syed’s conviction and ordered him to be launched – after 23 years behind bars.
Prosecutors now have 30 days to determine whether or not they’ll totally drop the costs or retry the case.
Timeline of the homicide of Hae Min Lee and authorized battle of Adnan Syed
Greater than twenty years on from his arrest for the homicide of his former girlfriend, Adnan Syed is ready to lastly stroll free from jail.
On Monday, Baltimore Metropolis Circuit Choose Melissa Phinn threw out the 41-year-old’s conviction and granted him a brand new trial, ordering his launch after spending the final 23 years behind bars.
Syed, who was 17 when he was accused of killing Hae Min Lee, can be launched from jail at present.
Syed’s sudden launch marks simply the most recent twist in a authorized battle that has rumbled on for greater than twenty years – and through which he has at all times maintained his innocence.
Learn a timeline of the case to date:
Adnan Syed case: Timeline of homicide of Hae Min Lee and authorized battle of the Serial podcast topic
Voices: Adnan Syed’s conviction ought to have been thrown out a very long time in the past
Twenty-two years in the past, Adnan Syed was convicted of murdering his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee. Lee, a scholar in Baltimore County, Maryland, was 18 years previous when she went lacking in January 1999. She was discovered useless of handbook strangulation in February of that yr. Syed, who was 17 on the time of Lee’s demise, was charged together with her homicide later that month; he was convicted a yr later and sentenced to life in jail.
Syed’s case got here to renewed consideration in 2014, with the launch of Serial, the podcast that modified the face of true-crime programming and forged doubt on the solidity of Syed’s conviction.
Over the course of 12 episodes, journalist Sarah Koenig, the present’s host, pointed to weaknesses within the proof used towards Syed, in addition to remaining idiosyncrasies and blurry areas. If there’s one central theme to Serial’s first season (the present had two extra, devoted to different subjects), it’s doubt — a vital issue, contemplating that the US justice system dictates that one ought to solely be convicted of a prison offense if the jury believes they’re responsible “past affordable doubt.”
The Impartial’s Clémence Michallon discusses the case:
This was the one doable conclusion in 2014, and it stays the one doable conclusion now, eight years later
The important thing points with the conviction:
Prosecutors have listed a number of points with Adnan Syed’s conviction, which led them to name for his launch “within the curiosity of equity and justice”.
Two alternate suspects
Proof has been discovered about two different potential suspects.
The 2 suspects, who weren’t named due to the continued investigation, have been each identified to the preliminary 1999 homicide investigation and weren’t correctly dominated out, prosecutors stated. One of many suspects had made a menace to kill Hae Min Lee.
The 2 suspects, who weren’t named due to the continued investigation, have been each identified to the preliminary 1999 homicide investigation however the state didn’t disclose the knowledge to Syed’s authorized crew.
The decide dominated that this was a transparent Brady violation – the place a prosecutor fails to offer the defence with proof that might be useful to a defendant’s case.
Validity of cellphone information
Cellphone location information inserting Syed on the crime scene has since been discovered to be inaccurate and inadmissible in court docket.
The prosecution additionally forged doubt on the credibility of Jay Wilds – the star witness within the state’s unique trial.
Wilds, a buddy of Syed’s, claimed that he helped Syed to get rid of Lee’s physique within the shallow grave in Leakin Park, Baltimore.
Prosecutors stated that Wilds has modified his story a number of occasions – with contradictions between his first interviews with police, his trial testimony and a latest interview with the press.
Detective on unique case
One of many most important detectives on the unique case, Invoice Ritz – who interviewed Wilds, was later accused of misconduct in one other 1999 homicide case.
The person convicted in that case was exonerated in 2016.
Transferring video exhibits Adnan Syed having fun with meals with household at house
A shifting video has captured Adnan Syed having fun with meals at his household house not lengthy afte his launch on Monday.
The footage, posted on Twitter by household buddy and lawyer Rabia Chaudry, exhibits the 41-year-old looking out by way of the fridge within the house, on the lookout for meals.
Syed is seen taking out samosas and dumplings whereas his brother Yusuf stands subsequent to him, fortunately grabbing and sharing the meals.
“We bought recent samosas coming although,” Ms Chaudry is heard saying.
Syed is seen making an attempt a dumpling and smiling, after twenty years of jail meals.
“Fairly good,” he says.
Ms Chaudry captioned the put up: “Leftovers at house by no means tasted so good!!”
New DNA testing below means
The state is ready for the outcomes of DNA testing which they hope may advance the investigation, Baltimore Metropolis State’s Lawyer Marilyn Mosby stated on Monday.
In March, prosecutors and Adnan Syed’s defence attorneys filed a joint request for Hae Min Lee’s clothes to be examined utilizing new contact DNA testing, which was not obtainable on the time of the unique trial.
The evaluation got here again in August with out something conclusive.
However, Ms Mosby stated on Monday that additional testing is below means.
She added that if the exams come again with Syed’s DNA, then her workplace would pursue a brand new case towards him.
However, both means, he’s nonetheless entitled to a brand new, honest trial, she stated – after mentioning a number of points together with his unique case.
What we find out about two alternate suspects in 1999 homicide
Adnan Syed walked out of court docket a free man on Monday, after an nearly year-long investigation uncovered new proof in regards to the doable involvement of two different suspects within the 1999 slaying of scholar Hae Min Lee.
On Monday, Baltimore Metropolis Circuit Choose Melissa Phinn vacated the 41-year-old’s conviction “within the curiosity of justice”, granted him a brand new trial and ordered him to be launched below house detention whereas the investigation into Lee’s homicide continues.
His launch got here days after Maryland prosecutors made a bombshell request for his conviction to be quashed.
On Wednesday – after greater than twenty years behind bars the place Syed has continued to take care of his innocence of any involvement – Baltimore Metropolis State’s Lawyer Marilyn Mosby filed a movement to throw out his conviction.
She stated that “the state now not has confidence within the integrity of the conviction” primarily based on doubts in regards to the validity of cellphone information in addition to new details about two unnamed suspects.
Wednesday’s court docket submitting didn’t title the 2 alternate suspects within the case, citing an ongoing investigation.
Nevertheless, prosecutors stated that the 2 alternate suspects have been each identified to the preliminary 1999 homicide investigation and weren’t correctly dominated out or disclosed to the defence.
The Impartial’s Rachel Sharp has the complete story:
The Serial podcast named Ronald Lee Moore, a profession prison and accused assassin from Baltimore, as a suspect in Hae Min Lee’s slaying
Hae Min Lee’s brother says case is ‘killing me’
Hae Min Lee’s brother addressed the court docket throughout Monday’s listening to to talk out in regards to the toll the case is taking up him and his household, saying that it’s “killing me”.
Younger Lee joined the court docket listening to nearly from the West Coast the place he urged the decide to “make the appropriate choice”.
“I’ve been residing with this for like 20 plus years. On a regular basis after I suppose it’s over… or it’s ended, it at all times comes again,” he stated.
“It’s killing me. It’s actually robust.”
He added that he felt “betrayed” by the prosecution, claiming they blindsided the household by casting doubt on Adnan Syed’s guilt – after spending greater than twenty years insisting he was the killer.
Mr Lee choked again tears as he stated that he was open to a brand new investigation and spoke of the issue in studying that somebody chargeable for his sister’s demise may at the moment be strolling free.
Adnan Syed was shedding ‘hope’ in freedom earlier than shock launch
Adnan Syed had been “making an attempt to tamp down hope” that he would ever regain his freedom, earlier than his shock launch on Monday, it has been revealed.
In a brand new episode of the podcast Serial, Sarah Koenig revealed that the 41-year-old had lately been shedding religion that his conviction can be overturned.
Syed was 17 when he was arrested and charged with strangling Hae Min Lee to demise in 1999.
He had spent the final 23 years behind bars.
On Monday, a decide overturned his conviction and ordered his launch.
Watch second Adnan Syed walks out of court docket a free man
Adnan Syed walked out of the court docket in Baltimore to cheers after the decide overturned his 2000 homicide conviction on Monday.
Watch the second he left the courthouse a free man beneath:
Serial host says Syed’s case includes ‘nearly each continual drawback’ in justice system
The host of the Serial podcast has stated that Adnan Syed’s case includes “nearly each continual drawback” within the prison justice system.
Journalist Sarah Koenig launched a brand new episode within the sequence on Tuesday – in the future after Syed walked out of court docket a free man following the vacating of his homicide conviction.
In it, Ms Koenig identified that just about the entire proof which casts doubt on his conviction was obtainable again when Hae Min Lee was murdered in 1999.
“Yesterday, there was plenty of discuss equity, however most of what the state put in that movement to vacate, all of the precise proof, was both identified or knowable to cops and prosecutors again in 1999,” she stated on the finish of the episode.
“So even on a day when the federal government publicly acknowledges its personal errors, it’s onerous to really feel cheered a few triumph of equity. As a result of we’ve constructed a system that takes greater than 20 years to self-correct. And that’s simply this one case.”